I’ve been to Iceland twice now—once in the fall for a longer road trip, and once in the winter for a short, snowy getaway—and I swear it felt like visiting two totally different countries. Both trips were incredible, but in such different ways. Fall had golden fields, waterfalls, and long scenic drives. Winter had snowy lava rocks, cozy cafés, and steam rising from warm pools into the freezing air.
So if you’re thinking about booking a trip (or you’re in full-blown planning mode already), here’s everything I wish someone had told me before I went the first time—plus a few of my favorite places, tips, and tools that made both trips extra special.
🍂 Fall vs. ❄️ Winter in Iceland
People always ask me “When’s the best time to go?” and honestly, it depends on what kind of trip you want.
On my fall trip, we rented a car and hit the road for 8 days. We explored the Ring Road Route, drove through remote villages, and even snorkeled between tectonic plates (yep, more on that below). It was adventurous and scenic, and we had so much space to just be in the landscape.
My winter trip was shorter—just 3 days—but still packed with magic. We stayed in Reykjavík, booked day tours to places like the Golden Circle and Secret Lagoon, and spent evenings wandering the cozy streets and drinking way too much hot cocoa. Totally different vibe, but still unforgettable.
🚗 To Rent a Car or Not?
If you’re staying 3 days or less, skip the rental. You can base yourself in Reykjavík and take day tours to most of the major sites. Iceland has a great tour infrastructure and it’s way less stressful (especially in winter).
For 5 days, it depends on your travel style. My guide gives options for both—some people want the freedom of driving, and others (hi, former winter traveler me) are happy to let someone else take the wheel.
7+ days? Renting a car opens up a lot more possibilities, especially if you want to explore places like Snaefellsnes or the East Fjords at your own pace. But don’t feel like you have to do the full Ring Road in a week—it’s a lot of driving. I’d recommend 8+ days if you really want to enjoy the full loop without feeling rushed.
If you decide to rent a car, I recommend booking through Expedia to compare options and find the best deal for your route and budget.
🏨 Favorite Reykjavík Hotel
On our second trip, we stayed at Eyja Guldsmeden Hotel, and I still dream about the breakfast. It had such a cool, cozy vibe—and best of all: free parking, walkable to everything, and the nicest staff. They gave us local food recommendations and hidden gem tips we wouldn’t have found otherwise.
If you’re spending a night or two in Reykjavík, I can’t recommend it enough.
💦 My Honest Take on the Blue Lagoon
Okay, I know the Blue Lagoon gets a lot of mixed reviews. A few of our tour guides even rolled their eyes at it. But listen—if you do the general admission, I get the criticism. It can feel super crowded and rushed.
BUT… if you’re up for a splurge, the Retreat Spa is completely different and totally worth it (IMO). You get your own private suite, access to peaceful spa areas, and a full ritual experience with steam rooms, clay masks, and more. And you can still head out into the main lagoon if you want the classic pic.
I’ve done the Retreat Spa on both trips and would 100% do it again.
🧊 That Time I Snorkeled Between Continents
Hands down, one of the coolest things I’ve ever done was snorkeling at Silfra, where the North American and Eurasian plates meet. The water is so clear it almost doesn’t look real. It’s freezing, don’t get me wrong—but they bundle you up in dry suits and warm you up with hot cocoa after. Totally bucket-list material.
You’ll need a car to get there, but I promise—it’s worth the extra effort.
👉 Here’s the tour I booked
🧭 Want Some Help Planning?
If you’re overwhelmed by all the options (been there), I’ve put together ready-to-use digital guides for 3, 5, and 7-day trips to Iceland. They include:
- Daily itineraries (morning, afternoon, and evening suggestions)
- Clickable booking links for hotels, tours, and more
- Travel tips and packing suggestions
- You can even bundle the travel guide with a Google Map for your travels with all locations pinned for you—including restaurants, viewpoints, and hidden gems— making navigating once you get there so much easier!
- Designed to work on your phone, tablet, or computer for easy travel days
Whether you want to do a guided trip, drive yourself, or just mix and match—there’s a version for you. Check them out here.
Quick Tips I Always Share:
✨ Layers are your best friend. The weather changes fast.
✨ Groceries will save you. Eating out is expensive, so stop at a Bonus or Kronan.
✨ Book in advance. Spas and popular tours sell out, especially in high season.
✨ Don’t try to do everything. Iceland is about the experience, not checking boxes.
No matter how long you stay or what time of year you go, Iceland will blow you away. It’s one of those rare places that feels both wild and peaceful, dramatic and cozy, all at once. I still think about it regularly—and I know I’ll be back again.
So, are you Team Road Trip or Team Reykjavík? Let me know in the comments—or if you’re ready to start planning, grab one of my guides and get excited. Iceland’s waiting. 💙
*This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate and participant in other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases. Read my full affiliate disclosure for more info.
